Digital Gift Cards vs. Physical Gift Cards: Which is Best?
Toasty 01/18/2025
6 Minutes

Introduction

Digital gift cards let people pick what they really want. Instead of guessing a friend’s favorite style or color, you offer them a flexible solution. Companies also love gift cards because they can reward employees or thank customers without storing large amounts of inventory.

Today, many businesses need to recognize staff members in different cities or even different countries. This is where digital gift cards truly shine, since they travel by email instead of the mailman.

With technology evolving each day, more shoppers go online to pick out products. Younger generations are already used to digital wallets and apps. They find it normal to buy and use digital gift cards without needing a piece of plastic in hand. Let’s see how this shift is taking place and why it matters.

 

Are you creating a gift card program, but are unsure where to start? Book a free consultation with one of our rewards specialists today!

 


Physical vs. Digital Gift Cards

The Rise of Gift Cards

Gift cards have been big business for many years. They solve a common problem: finding the perfect gift. Whether for birthdays or employee milestones, gift cards offer freedom of choice and a quick way to say, “I appreciate you.”

While we once saw mostly plastic or paper cards, online technology has paved the way for digital gift cards. As more people shop on their phones or computers, digital gifting is becoming the preferred way to share rewards.

 

Understanding Physical Cards

Physical gift cards are often made of plastic and sold on racks in many stores. They can feel nice to unwrap and hand to someone face-to-face. Some people also like the idea of a physical card tucked in a greeting card envelope for birthdays or holidays.

But these plastic cards can be lost, stolen, or easily forgotten at home. Plus, printing and shipping them can cost extra money and time, especially for bigger companies that hand out lots of cards each year.

 

Defining Digital Gift Cards

Digital gift cards are an online version of physical gift cards. Instead of getting a plastic card, you get a code digitally. You redeem that code online or show it at a store checkout.

Digital cards are quick to send, don’t clutter your wallet, and work well for people living in different places. Because they exist purely online, they are also better for the planet. Fewer items are produced, which means less waste overall.

 


Key Benefits of Digital Gift Cards

Convenience and Speed

One huge benefit of digital gift cards is that they can be delivered instantly. If you remember someone’s birthday at the last minute, you can buy and send them a card in seconds.

For companies, sending digital rewards to remote employees is a breeze. There is no need to wait days for mail delivery. This quick turnaround gives people a real-time “thank you,” which boosts morale and motivation.

Have you ever had a physical gift card lost in the mail? It happens more often than you would think, especially during the holidays, and it is usually not an easy process to get a replacement sent out. 

 

Lower Costs and No Up-Charges

Physical cards often come with extra charges for printing, packaging, and shipping. These costs can add up, especially if you need to reward a large group. In contrast, digital gift cards arrive electronically and require fewer materials.

Some platforms also follow a no up-charge model, meaning if you buy a $50 card, the recipient gets the full $50. The Toasty Choice Card uses this approach, making it a very transparent option for businesses. You pay exactly what you load on the card, with no hidden fees eating into your reward budget.

 

Eco-Friendliness

We hear a lot about reducing waste and protecting the planet. Physical gift cards are often made from plastics that do not break down easily. Over time, discarded plastic cards can stack up in landfills.

Some providers of physical gift cards are moving toward more sustainable materials, but less pollution is still more than no pollution.

By switching to digital gift cards, you eliminate that trash. There is no plastic card to throw away and no extra packaging to ship. If your company wants to show eco-friendly values, a digital reward program is a simple step in the right direction.

 

Fitting a Tech-Savvy World

We use our phones and computers for just about everything: chatting, banking, shopping, and more. Digital gift cards fit right into this new lifestyle. Younger people, like Gen Z, find it very natural to buy, store, and redeem e-gift cards on their devices.

Even older generations are learning to appreciate the ease of digital. As this tech trend continues, physical cards may feel outdated. Going digital proves you are modern and forward-thinking.

 

Myths, Technical Hurdles, and Security

Some say digital gift cards are less personal than physical cards. But you can still add a caring message or unique design to an e-card. Another myth is that digital versions are risky, yet Toasty uses innovative encryption and other security measures to keep codes safe.

In fact, physical cards are easier targets for fraudulent actors, as there are many points of vulnerability between when the card is manufactured and when it is given to your recipients. 

Storage is another concern with physical gift cards, as they are often active once you receive them. Unless they are stored in an secure and access controlled room, there are opportunities for malfeasant actors to get their hands on them. 

In contrast, digital gift cards give you much more flexibility and security. Additionally, if someone loses an email, the sender can reissue a new code with ease via the Toasty portal. This is much harder to do with a lost plastic card.

 


Using Digital Gift Cards in Reward Programs

Enhancing Employee and Customer Rewards

Gift cards are perfect for celebrating achievements in the workplace. Maybe a salesperson hits a big monthly goal, or a support team member goes above and beyond.

Sending them digital gift cards is a fast way to say, “Great job!” Instead of waiting for a big end-of-year bonus, workers get instant recognition. This can boost morale and even increase loyalty to the company. The timely recognition also creates a stronger association between the positive behavior and the reward. 

Customers also love a free shopping opportunity. If someone is a loyal buyer, sending them a small digital gift card can spark more purchases. They feel valued and might recommend your business to friends. A single digital card can lead to a chain of happy interactions that strengthen your brand.

 

Flexibility for Recipients

Physical cards usually lock you into one store or brand. If you do not like that brand, the card might get lost before it ever gets used. With digital gift cards, there are often multiple options to choose from.

For example, the Toasty Choice Card allows the recipient to pick from many different retailers or experiences. This choice means everyone gets something they truly want. By making rewards more personal, the company sees higher redemption rates, which means money is well spent.

Pro Tip: Your recipient can get multiple different gift cards with a Toasty Choice Card. For example, with a $20 Toasty Choice Card, they could get a $15 Wal-Mart gift card and a $5 Amazon gift card. 

 

Frequent Recognition

One reason digital gift cards are so effective is their low cost and quick delivery. Instead of giving one big reward a year, companies can hand out smaller gifts more often.

Regular positive feedback builds a strong team culture. Imagine a monthly contest where the top performer gets a $20 e-gift code. It is a small amount, but immediate recognition keeps people excited and engaged. Digital cards make that quick, easy, and budget-friendly.

 

Building Customer Loyalty

Digital gift cards do not just work for employees. They can also be a great tool to keep customers happy. Many businesses use e-gift cards as a reward for taking surveys or as a “thank you” after big purchases.

Sending an e-card to a high-value client shows appreciation and might encourage them to become repeat customers. Since digital cards can be redeemed on most devices, it is a convenient perk that feels like free money.

 

Handling Bulk Orders and Data Insights

Managing hundreds or thousands of plastic cards takes time, physical space, and shipping effort. With digital gift cards, all you need is an email list. You can send out bulk codes at once, track when they are redeemed (with the Toasty Refund Option), and easily reissue cards.

This data can help you tailor future rewards, plan budgets, and spot trends in employee or customer behavior. If someone does not redeem their card, you can send them a friendly reminder, all without digging through drawers full of plastic or picking up the phone.

 


The Toasty Choice Card

Why Toasty Stands Out

Among the many digital gift cards out there, the Toasty Choice Card brings something unique: it has no up-charges, offers flexible brand options, and is super easy to send.

When you buy a card for $50, you only pay $50. There are no hidden fees, and your recipient gets the full amount to spend. The wide variety of brands means your employees or customers can pick something they truly want, whether it’s new tech gadgets, clothing, or a meal from their favorite restaurant.

 

Personalization and Branding

Companies can customize the toasty choice card to fit their brand. This might include adding a company logo or including a special message. For example, if you are sending a birthday gift to an employee, you can add a cheery note or a fun graphic.

If your team is global, you do not need to worry about shipping times or different currency conversions. Your staff simply receives their digital gift cards by email and redeems them wherever they live. It is easy, personal, and perfect for the modern workplace.

 


Conclusion

The Future of Gift Cards

As technology continues to evolve, the popularity of digital gift cards will only grow. We may soon see more features, such as gift cards tied to gaming apps, virtual reality platforms, or community fundraisers.

People want more flexibility in their rewards, and digital solutions offer just that. With many people shopping online, an e-card matches the way they already live and shop. As businesses adapt to remote teams and global markets, digital gifting is a natural fit.

 

Making the Smart Choice

When deciding between a physical card and a digital one, think about the speed, cost, and eco-friendly nature of digital gift cards. For companies that want to keep workers excited and customers loyal, digital cards are often the best solution.

They arrive instantly, can be tracked, and are kinder to the planet. The Toasty Choice Card in particular stands out because it lets the sender avoid up-charges and the recipient choose the brand they want most.

Whether it’s a birthday present for a friend, an employee perk, or a thank-you to a loyal customer, e-gifting is a fast, user-friendly option that matches today’s lifestyles. Give it a try and see how simple and effective it can be to say “thanks” in a digital-first world.

 

Book a Demo
Create a Free Account


Tag: